Who is Really Oppressing Who?
First off, I need to say that I consider myself a progressive person, but this may deviate from the typical progressive philosophy and ideals. This is very near and dear to me and in light of the story about Barack Obama’s Pastor, Rev. Jeremiah Wright, I feel that I need to address the issue of race in America.
I am a biracial woman (black/white), and I like to think that I see the world in a very fair way when it comes to racial issues, but this article may prove otherwise. I read an article by titled “Sick and Tired-And White,” by Arnold Ahlert. He talked about how Rev. Wright’s comments, which apparently are typical of the sermons in Black churches, keep black people from succeeding. I have to say that I agree.
My parents and teachers always expected me to do well, which does not imply perfection, but does mean working hard and giving one's best. But because of those expectations, I did very well in school and extra-curricular activities. As a person of color, I was always expected to join black student unions, protest some event that people saw as racist, etc. But whenever I attempted to interact with groups that focused on being a minority, I was often laughed at and made fun of for being "too white," i.e., speaking proper English, valuing my education, or anything else that was deemed white. I was never labeled “too white” by a white person. I never understood how some people who claim to identify so much with their oppressed ancestors are so prejudiced. How can some black people decide what is "black enough"? Did they ever stop and think that the characteristics that make someone "black enough" are not positive attributes and that it does not eliminate racism, but probably makes it worse? Do they realize that limiting someone to offensive racial stereotypes is the ultimate form of self-loathing? Did they know that it was against the law for their ancestors who were slaves to be educated? Do they realize the indignities that their ancestors suffered in America, and can they compare that to an ignorant person hurling a slur and realize the difference is like night and day? Has anyone figured out that the anger that is emanated from black student union meetings and pulpits is not working? Is anyone offended by being a “perpetual victim” so people like Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson can remain famous (I sure am!)? Do the same people who insist Martin Luther King, Jr. Day be celebrated with a day off of work and school realize that he valued education and most likely would not appreciate that most of us (myself included) “honor him” by sleeping in or going to the mall one Monday every January? These questions never seem to come up, and I believe it is because many people are afraid to ask them for fear of being labeled a racist or sellout.
Vocal Black "leaders" need to remind other blacks about racism and how unfair life is because they would be out of a job. The NAACP does an excellent job of sounding the alarm when an incident that is deemed racist occurs, but they become inept (by choice in my opinion) when it comes to coming up with solutions. I know that there is racism in America, but there will always be people with narrow-minded viewpoints. There are always going to be extremists that want to kill everyone who doesn't think like them. Extremists are often uneducated, frustrated individuals looking to belong and they do so by becoming part of a group that identifies themselves by dehumanizing “others.” I believe the best argument against racism is for blacks to succeed in achieving their vision of the American Dream.
The history of slavery in America is not pretty but I believe that the America of the past is nothing like American now.
Personally, I find the idea of a church with a racial label in front of “church” appalling. All of us are God’s children and Jesus died for everybody. As a Christian, I believe the best place to start healing the racial divisions is in the Christian Church. What better way for us who are called to follow Christ to set an example of His love and salvation?
- klhayes's blog
- Login or register to post comments












A new role model?
Kristie,
Great post. So you can relate to Sen. Obama is some ways.
It strikes me that, consciously or not, Sen. Obama is developing a new role model for the African-american community. He's struggled mightly to discover his roots, from Africa and Kansas and who knows where before that. His mother was quite a powerful lady whose imprint we clearly see on him.
He seems to be finding his own identity and in the process helping others find theirs. Sen. Clinton famously found her voice in New Hampshire. Now he seems to be finding his, as you have. I can only hope that he helps other young black people, especially men, find their voices.
Peace,
Rich
to klhayes
Thanks for another excellent well thought out post klhayes. Your other posts were excellent too. We are always looking for a few good bloggers, have you ever thought about becoming a "featured blogger"?
I don't agree with Arnold Ahlert and much that is in your post, but you present it well. Write some more !!
interesting take Kristie
Kristie,
Thanks for your very thoughtful comments here. As a white guy, I tread carefully when it comes to making judgments about race relations. I think you make some very poignant points about the role of personal responsiblity and the community needing to give greater value to education. I'm very interested, how would you square your thoughts with Obama's speech today? There seems to be a good deal of commonality.
There's one point where I have a small disagreement and that is your not seeing the need for a "black church". The black church has a very important historical role within the black community and indeed for our nation. The black church formed out of resistance and out of the prejudice from those in the white church who didn't want to worship with African Americans. Since a very early time, the black church has been the place where black folk could develop a positive self-identity, assume positions of leadership, and find emotional and spiritual support. The black chuch was and in many cases is the bedrock of many communities providing services to the poor and uplift to the community.
In American history, the black church has been a central force in the struggle for social and racial justice. King, Rosa Parks, and all the anonymous foot soldiers of the civil rights movement came out of and were sustained by the black church. When many white churches were advocating for Jim Crow and racism, the black church stood tall in the fight for equality.
While I certainly would like Sunday to be more integrated, I do think that the black church plays a valid and indeed vital role within many black communities. Its been my experience that white folks are more than welcome, but many white folks won't go into black churches.
Whites visiting African-American Churches
I have visited several African American churches, including one in Detroit that Aretha Franklin's father was pastor of, years ago. I always found the church goers warm and usually welcoming.I never had a negative remark, a few quizical glances, but that is about all.