Universal Health Care
Hello Crossleft Community,
The following paper was written by my daughter, Ellen Vance Loyd, for an English class...Yep, I'm proud of her and thought this paper to be timely.
Gary
Universal Health Care
Over the last few decades, the United States has experienced soaring costs in health care and there is a growing debate about the possible solutions. The number of uninsured Americans is increasing because of out of control costs. Many millions of Americans lacks any form of health insurance and millions more have inadequate coverage. It has become clear that health care for all is something that must be achieved.
The lack of healthcare for all Americans has become a moral issue that must be addressed. The United States is the only industrialized nation that does not have some form of universal healthcare guaranteed for all citizens as stated on the website sponsored by Sojourners Magazine, in an article entitled “Healthcare RX for the System” (par 6). Other countries have declared health care to be a basic right while the United States treats health care as a privilege for those who can afford it.
The 2005 Employer Health Benefits Survey found on the website sponsored by the Kaiser Family Foundation shows health insurance premiums have been rising on average by double-digit percentage points over the past five years while the percentage of employers offering health insurance dropped from 69% in 2000 to 60% in 2005. Many employers are only able to provide high-deductible insurance that covers less and less healthcare costs. The net result is that more employed middle-class Americans find themselves with low quality healthcare or no access at all. Offering Universal Healthcare would improve the health of the people in our country and save them money.
There are a variety of reasons people give to oppose the idea of Universal Healthcare. The United States has the largest hospitals and clinics with the best trained doctors and nurses of any industrialized nation. Therefore, many believe it would be too risky to make any major changes in our system.
Lifestyles people choose can have a direct effect on their health, so some argue that people making healthy choices should not have to pay for care of people who refuse to. Some oppose Universal Healthcare because they believe it would have to be paid for with much higher taxes. They feel that wiping out a few hundred dollars a month in insurance premiums would not make up for the higher tax rates required to pay for health care. The government must pay for this somehow, as noted on the website sponsored by Balanced Politics, in the article entitled “Should the Government Provide Free Universal Healthcare for All Americans?”(par 9)
Though many people believe the United States has the best healthcare in the world, it is a fact that our country ranks twenty-third in infant mortality, as stated on the website sponsored by Connecticut Coalition for Universal Healthcare. Kao-Ping Chua, with the American Medical Student Association, notes on the website sponsored by AMSA that, “The World Health Organization ranks our healthcare system thirty-seventh on overall performance, and twenty-fourth on health level attainment.”(par 12)
It is true that many people suffer with disease because of poor lifestyle choices, but many have illness because of other reasons like genetics, aging and accidents. Regardless, all people who are sick need care. Universal Healthcare would assist patients with counseling who need to make changes in how they live. The tax increase to pay for healthcare would be offset by wage increases since employers would not have to pay for health insurance.
Life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness are supposed to be basic rights of all Americans. How can we tolerate a system that denies people medications and treatments that could be lifesaving? Is it acceptable to deny people healthcare based on their ability to pay? Or is healthcare a basic need that should be provided for every citizen? It is time to change the American healthcare system and create a society in which healthcare is available for all.
Works Cited
Battista, John R. “Case for Universal Healthcare in the United States.”
Connecticut Coalition for Universal Healthcare. Nov. 27, 2007, www.cthealth.server101.com
Bonnyman, Gordon “Healthcare RX for the System.” Sojourners. Nov. 11, 2007,
www.sojo.net (vol. 36, no. 2 pp 15-16)
Chau, Kao-Ping “Arguments and Counterarguments About Universal Healthcare.”
American Medical Student Association. Nov. 11, 2007, www.amsa.com
Kaiser Family Foundation, “2005 Employer Health Benefits Summary of Findings.”
Nov. 11, 2007 www.kff.org
Messerli, Joe “Should the Government Provide Free Universal Healthcare For All
Americans?” Balanced Politics. Nov. 27, 2007, www.balancedpolitics.org
- Gary Vance's blog
- Login or register to post comments

Comments
to Ellen
You've written a very good and comprehensive paper on universal health care. Taught the old dog (that's me) some new tricks (thoughts really but I had to stick with the phrase). There are a lot of potential plans out there (Angelo left a most awesome list of links) and they say the devil's in the details, but I sort of think that if we can figure out just exactly what we want to accomplish, our reasons for that, and the old bugaboo "who's gonna pay?" then the details don't much matter to me.
My dad is rock solid against universal health care, even though he's on medicare now (says after 80 years of paying taxes, it's his due). But he won't go to the VA (Veterans Administration Hospitals/Clinics) even though he's qualified for free health care there, says that's why he worked hard all his life so he didn't have to go to the VA. Says the federal government is the wrong entity to manage health care, and the VA is the proof. He also says that Rush Limbaugh is too liberal, just so you can see where he sits on the political thought spectrum. He's also a cute, funny, passionate old geezer who will never seem old to me. Nonetheless, I think he's wrong about universal health care (for many of the reasons you mentioned in your paper). He asks me why I want to pay more taxes, but it's not the cost that affects my answer. I have minimum standards on quality of life, and our current system doesn't meet my minimum standards.
I tell him he hasn't hung with enough poor people, he says "that's a bad thing?" and yes, in this case I think it is a bad thing. If you have no clue how some people live, then you've got to go buy a clue somewhere. And that's money you could be spending on higher taxes for universal health care. :)
Thanks for letting your dad share your paper. It did a good job of consolidating my thoughts for me.
AMA Plan
Angelo,
Thanks for the comprehensive list of links to various health care plans. The link below is to the AMA plan...
http://voicefortheuninsured.org/index.html
Thanks Gary. Is there any plan that you particularly favor?
Thanks Gary for the AMA link? Is there a particular plan that you favor?
Angelo
Thank Ellen for the paper on Universal Health Care
Gary, your daughter's paper is very good. You should be proud. Ellen offers a good information on the growing inability of average people and businesses to keep up with medical costs. I tried checking some of the links at the end and had trouble finding my way through the websites. The last link was very good in balancing the pro and con arguments of the universal health care debate.
Angelo
Thanks Angelo
Thanks Angelo,
Yeah, she put together a nice paper. I am glad Obama is intent on pushing toward some form of coverage for all citizens. It's hard to believe we have him as our leader...
Gary
Ideas for Universal Health Care
Here are some sites about ideas in universal health care. I support universal health care, but am not sure what is the best way to get it. Ellen's post could be a good starting point on a debate on ideas for the best universal health care plan.
The Obama Plan
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB122152292213639569.html
http://www.thehealthcareblog.com/the_health_care_blog/2008/03/a-detailed...
http://www.barackobama.com/issues/healthcare/
Single Payer Health Care
http://www.pnhp.org/facts/single_payer_resources.php
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single-payer_health_care
The Green Party Health Care Plan
http://www.ontheissues.org/Celeb/Green_Party_Health_Care.htm
Libertarian Party Health Care Plan
http://www.lp.org/issues/healthcare
Hillary Clinton Health Care plan
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/03/05/us/politics/05healthcare.html?_r=1
http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/72229.php
Ralph Nader Health Care Plan
http://www.votenader.org/issues/social/healthcare/#65995
Labor Party Health Care Plan
http://lpa.igc.org/documents/jhc_financing.html